Succession Challenges: When the Next Generation Declines the Opportunity

In 2024, Deloitte found 63% of family business identified "interest in succession" as a significant risk to their organization's succession planning. This shift threatens operational continuity, strategic direction, core purpose, and long-term sustainability.

Drawing on our expertise, we’ve helped family businesses navigate their options and chart a successful path forward.

Here’s how family businesses can navigate these challenges and build a sustainable succession strategy.

Understanding Why Successors Opt Out

Increasingly, younger generations are encouraged to carve their own path, without being tethered to the vision or passion of older generations. We’re also seeing the growing appeal of entrepreneurship and corporate careers in high-growth industries divert potential successors away from legacy businesses.

Global career opportunities and changing personal priorities around work-life balance and autonomy also contribute significantly, making family business leadership roles less appealing than in previous generations. This shift is particularly pronounced in families where financial security has already been established, reducing the financial necessity of joining the business.

Family successors often perceive limited autonomy within the established framework of a family enterprise. This can result in feelings of being overshadowed by the founding generation's legacy or constrained by family expectations.

Without a solid foundation in the board room, the family room, or the owner room, successors may struggle to see clear career paths or opportunities to make meaningful contributions.

Preparing for External Leadership Without Losing Family Influence

When family succession isn't feasible, external leadership is required. This transition begins by defining and communicating the family's core values, mission, and long-term objectives. Formalizing these principles through a family charter embeds them into the organization's foundation, while integrating KPIs ensures accountability and measurable impact.

Effective family governance is essential in this process. This includes structured boards and family councils, which can help external executives clearly understand and align with the family's core values and long-term objectives. Distinguishing between family influence and an external operational control empowers leaders while preserving strategic alignment. 

Those unspoken rules, traditions, or legacy decisions that are rarely challenged. The key is identifying where they can add value without disrupting the business’s long-term vision.

Governance practices also facilitate cooperation, enabling external executives to integrate into the company culture without diminishing family influence. Part of this is open, regular communication between the family and external executives, which builds mutual trust, enabling transparent decision-making and strategic alignment.

Cultural integration, though sometimes unclear, is also important to consider. Providing new leaders with deep exposure to the family business’s history, values, and long-term objectives, helps to maintain the established culture. As does designing executive compensation structures that incentivize long-term value creation in line with the family’s mission.

Maintaining Family Engagement and Legacy

Even when leadership transitions involve external candidates, preserving family engagement remains crucial. Active involvement in philanthropic initiatives or corporate social responsibility projects under the family brand can reinforce legacy and emotional connections among family members. 

Offering structured training in business management, entrepreneurship, and governance to develop future family members also ensures continuity – even if they do not take on direct leadership roles.

Addressing potential tensions between family legacy and practical business decisions is essential. Working alongside a trusted independent advisor can add support during these tougher conversations. Transparent processes for managing family dynamics, including clear criteria for involvement and roles for family members who remain outside daily operations, help sustain interest and ensure continued support.

Leveraging Independent Expertise

External advisors play a critical role in facilitating these transitions, bringing objectivity and professional guidance. Executive search can define leadership criteria, manage expectations, asses cultural fit, and identify candidates who respect and embody family values. External leadership assessment can also be applied to internal candidates, setting the company up for a smoother transition when onboarding a new executive.

Similarly, establishing an independent advisory board can introduce professional management structures that ensure long-term sustainability. These experts provide strategic oversight and impartial decision-making.

It’s worth remembering that although navigating family business succession without willing internal successors poses significant challenges, it also presents opportunities for professional growth, enhanced governance, and sustained legacy. By embracing external leadership thoughtfully and maintaining meaningful family involvement, these enterprises can continue thriving for generations.

___________________________________________________________

Get in touch. Follow the links below to discover more, or contact our dedicated leadership experts from your local Odgers Berndtson office here.